|
I had trouble finding an armband for the older 3G I have so this item was a great find. Easy to use and comfortable. Great service and quick delivery was appreciated.
This armband was better than I had originally thought it would be. I had an Apple Ipod armband that did the job but unfastened from time to time when I working out. I'm not a bulky guy so I did not have a problem with it stretching to fit my bicep. The look of the band is black and very sleek and so far is of solid construction.
I read the reviews prior to ordering, but took a chance anyway. Unfortunately it is falling apart on the velcro strip just as others had reported. Ugh.
Sleek, fits nicely on my trim (not muscular or fat but not super skinny) arm. The front plastic cover is not sewn. Thus it separates from the neoprene with any kind of moisture. Seller was gracious enough to send me a new one, but it turns out that the product just doesn't work for running 30 minutes three times a week.
- I find that the plastic cover interferes with the controls no matter what so I cut a circular opening for it. If it does slide it will disconnect or pull on my earphones so I'll know. That was okay for me because I was going to give it to my son if I couldn't wear it. I was looking for something a little cheaper than the XtremeMac so I thought I give others a try.
- The Case Logic does not have a bottom opening for the lock, nor does it have a top flap to keep nano secure. - Case Logic has the next longest length and it's band stretches too. Best nano case fit: XtremeMac & Belkin- Both have an opening at the bottom for the earphones and for the nano lock. Hang tight this is lengthy.I bought the "Belkin Neoprene Sports Armband for iPod nano 3G" (~$20) and the "Case Logic True Sport Armband for iPod nano 3G (Light Blue) (~$22)". Note: Armband does looks similar, but not exactly, like what I saw when I ordered it. I play music randomly and just need good control access. - I've given the Belkin to my young son which is fine for him.
It barely got around my arm and I don't consider myself to have big arms (wish I could say otherwise). Case Logic 1) Has a credit card holder behind the nano case. (Older model). - Belkin has the shortest strap and it does not stretch. I read other reviews which said the Belkin did not fit normal sized men. You could also use this to hold a key too. 2) Nano compartment is sewn on. (I primarily keep my ipod in the sports armband).Other intangibles: Belkin 1) Has a keep holder - it's too small for my house key.
- Both have the little flap that wraps over the top of the nano to keep it secure. On the flip side it is easier to remove from the case. - It's a nicety, but I don't really need a key or credit card compartment. I currently have the "XtremeMac Sportwrap Armband for iPod nano 3G" (~$30) which needs to be replaced since it abused after several years of use. Summary:- I personally prefer the XtremeMac in all around fit.
XtremeMac 1) Does not have a place for a key or credit card. - However, I'm keeping the CaseLogic because.a) The slightly blurry plastic cover does not matter much to me since I'm not watching music videos, movies, or necessarily need to see the cover album. b) I don't think the nano will slide out (note I wear my armband upside down so the controls are facing upward for easy access). 2) Nano compartment is not sewn on. Best armstrap fit: XtremeMac- XtremeMac has the longest strap and it's a little stretchy too.
I can push the plastic down if I really need to see something. - In the Case Logic, the nano does not fit as snugly as the others (although it does not appear to move so far) and therefore the plastic moves away from the nano and makes the screen display a little blurry. I would be concerned about it falling out. I use the armband while I'm practicing Karate or walking. I can always put it so controls are face down if necesasry.c) Since I'll be cutting out the plastic to have easier access to the controls, I'll also cut a small opening for the nano lock (we have an exacto knife handy).
|
